A Clash of Faiths: Ridley Scott’s Body of Lies

Ridley Scott

Body of Lies movie poster

 

Rid­ley Scott’s fol­low up to the gen­tle com­edy of A Good Year (read The Dork Report review) and the crime drama Amer­i­can Gang­ster (partly mod­eled, I think, on Michael Mann’s epic Heat), returns to the politically-themed yet still action-oriented ter­ri­tory he first vis­ited in Black Hawk Down. The key dif­fer­ence here is that, like Peter Weir’s The King­dom and Pete Travis’ Van­tage Point (read The Dork Report review), Body of Lies is set in a fan­ta­sy­land safely divorced from the very, very real events that inspired Black Hawk Down. All of these films have the air of gritty real­ism, but still indulge in the wish ful­fill­ment of a very cin­e­matic war on terror.

Body of Lies can be seen as com­plet­ing a kind of Mid­dle East tril­ogy for Scott, after the afore­men­tioned Black Hawk Down plus the Cru­sades epic King­dom of Heaven (read The Dork Report review). Screen­writer William Mon­a­han wrote both King­dom of Heaven and Body of Lies (adapted from the novel by David Ignatius). But of the three, Body of Lies is clearly the least serious.

Russell Crowe and Leonardo DiCaprio in Body of LiesMesopotamia, and step on it!

No doubt movie stu­dio exec­u­tives have cal­cu­lated down to the last cent that world audi­ences are still too sen­si­tive to actual ter­ror­ist attacks like Lon­don and Madrid in order to buy tick­ets for dra­matic recre­ations on the big screen. Instead, most main­stream terrorism-themed movies are basi­cally enter­tain­ments that only have the feel of seri­ous import, and none of the sub­stance. Body of Lies invents anal­o­gous ter­ror­ist attacks such as a sleeper cell blow­ing up their Lon­don flat, and later, the bomb­ing of a U.S. marine base in Turkey (I hope O’Neal — Demi Moore — from Scott’s G.I. Jane — read The Dork Report Review — wasn’t sta­tioned there). Van­tage Point is a lit­tle more cre­ative in imag­in­ing a worst-case-scenario of a pres­i­den­tial assas­si­na­tion, but has no inter­est in the reper­cus­sions beyond a Rashomon-like recount­ing of the imme­di­ate aftermath.

So audi­ences get films like this, where shad­owy CIA oper­a­tives sneak around Iraq and Jor­dan, sav­ing the world from Islamic fun­da­men­tal­ism. They have seem­ingly lim­it­less resources but no gov­ern­ment over­sight, and any­thing is pos­si­ble with a lit­tle com­puter hack­ing. Mean­while, more seri­ous and real­is­tic movies are ignored, like In the Val­ley of Elah (read The Dork Report review) and the truly excel­lent but emo­tion­ally dev­as­tat­ing United 93. In com­par­i­son, Scott’s Black Hawk Down was unafraid to recre­ate actual events still raw in the Amer­i­can public’s mem­ory: the cat­a­strophic marine incur­sion into Soma­lia in 1993. And even to limit the scope to Scott’s own oeu­vre, King­dom of Heaven is a much smarter con­sid­er­a­tion of the clash of faiths in the Mid­dle East.

Leonardo DiCaprio and Golshifteh Farahani in Body of LiesLeo meets cute with an Iran­ian nurse (Gol­shifteh Farahani)

Body of Lies is Rus­sell Crowe’s fourth film with Scott, fol­low­ing Glad­i­a­tor, A Good Year, and Amer­i­can Gang­ster. Here, he packs on some seri­ous poundage to enter the same schlubby mode he debuted in Michael Mann’s The Insider, sea­soned with a lit­tle of the crass bas­tard he played in A Good Year. Leonardo DiCaprio, on tem­po­rary loan from Mar­tin Scors­ese, sports a scrappy beard but still looks like a teenager. The pretty boy is con­stantly get­ting beaten up, cut, bruised, and los­ing fin­gers. But he meets cute with pretty Iran­ian nurse Aisah (Gol­shifteh Fara­hani), so that’s alright, then.


Offi­cial movie site: www.body-of-lies.com

Buy any of these fine prod­ucts from Ama­zon and kick back a few pen­nies to The Dork Report:

 


Ridley Scott’s A Good Year

Ridley Scott

A Good Year movie poster

 

Scott returns to France for the first time since his 1977 fea­ture film debut The Duel­lists (read The Dork Report review) for the fluffy souf­flé A Good Year. Max­imil­lian Skin­ner (Rus­sell Crowe) — hardly the most sub­tle of names — is a self-proclaimed ass­hole that inher­its his uncle’s wine­mak­ing estate in Provence. His Uncle Henry (Albert Finney, who also appeared in The Duel­lists) raised him there, but evi­dently failed to impart the kinds of life lessons that would have moulded Skin­ner into a decent human being capa­ble of savor­ing the joys of life. The ideal life as defined in the film is essen­tially every­thing that a life of leisure in Provence pro­vides: namely, wine and women. But Skinner’s life in Lon­don is made up of much of the very same, so the solu­tion to fix­ing Skinner’s poi­soned soul is not to add some­thing that is miss­ing, but rather to sub­tract some­thing: his ass­hole­ness. Skin­ner does some­times man­i­fest some self-awareness; one moment he seems to gen­uinely rel­ish his life as the most venal of Lon­don stock­bro­kers, but the next he pro­fesses a love we’ve never before seen for his uncle and the sim­ple life of Provence.

Marion Cotillard and Russell Crowe in A Good YearRus­sell Crowe views his hand­i­work, writ large upon Mar­ion Cotillard’s derrière

Skinner’s waver­ing char­ac­ter com­ple­ments a num­ber of con­fus­ing plot holes. A run­ning mys­tery is the mys­te­ri­ous prove­nance of an excep­tional “garage wine” (lim­ited batches by tiny oper­a­tions, some­times lit­er­ally in a garage). Didier (Fran­cis Dulot), the long­time ten­der of the Skin­ner vin­yard, admits to delib­er­ately pro­duc­ing undrink­ably vile wine under the vinyard’s ban­ner, in an attempt to run down the value of the place and hope­fully dis­in­ter­est Skin­ner in sell­ing it. But is he simul­ta­ne­ously direct­ing his real tal­ents into the mak­ing of the mys­te­ri­ous garage wine? The plot thread is dropped and we never learn for sure. The cool clos­ing cred­its make the film seem more enter­tain­ingly screw­ball than it actu­ally was, and there’s also an utterly bewil­der­ing coda involv­ing Skinner’s snarky assis­tant Gemma (Archie Pan­jabi) meet­ing a rap­per and his agent. Huh?

Marion Cotillard and Russell Crowe in A Good YearRus­sell Crowe learns what’s impor­tant in life: hot French girls

I’m not sure if Crowe has the same sort of Cary Grant-like appeal for women that George Clooney has in spades, but there is plenty of eye candy for male view­ers. The lus­cious Cal­i­forn­ian back­packer Christie (Abbie Cor­nish) appears on Skinner’s doorstep claim­ing to be his only blood rel­a­tive, and thus a rival to his inher­i­tance of the estate. French actress Mar­ion Cotil­lard would later dis­guise her­self very unflat­ter­ingly to play the frail, sickly Edith Piaf in the turgid biopic La Vie En Rose, but here she uncorks her full-on Gal­lic gor­geous­ness as Fanny (again, another of the movie’s unsub­tle names — for she rather spec­tac­u­larly lifts her skirt in an out­doors café, to the delight of the entire town and, admit­tedly, this Dork Reporter). One of the fun­ni­est recur­ring gags is the pri­apic Skinner’s help­less dou­ble­takes to any of many dis­plays of ripe breasts and bums. But unfor­tu­nately, one of the other recur­ring jokes is his repeated invol­un­tary expo­sures to ani­mal dung.

Abbie Cornish in A Good YearAbbie Cor­nish as the cousin Skin­ner wishes he didn’t have, for more rea­sons than one

A Good Year takes quite a long time to get going, but does seem to pick up some comedic energy once Skinner’s cold Lon­don heart defrosts while court­ing Fanny in the sec­ond act. Rid­ley Scott can always be counted for fine art direc­tion and cin­e­matog­ra­phy, but here he wields his tal­ents bluntly. Even the color tem­per­a­ture is clichéd, lest any view­ers miss the point; Provence is amber-hued, and Lon­don is steely elec­tric blue. The right choice for Skin­ner is never in doubt; liv­ing on a wine­mak­ing estate in Provence with a beau­ti­ful French girl is a fan­tasy prob­a­bly every human being on earth shares, ass­hole or not.


Offi­cial movie site: www.agoodyear.com

Buy any of these fine prod­ucts from Ama­zon and kick back a few pen­nies to The Dork Report: